Their daily menu consists of five standard meals, two of which are fish and chips. One is made with the signature cod and the other with fresh caught perch. The perch is caught along the coast of Italy and is brought over to the restaurant without having to be frozen before being fried up and served. This gives Fins and Gills an edge on the fish and chips market if you are looking for crisp, flakey, fresh and delicious fish and chips. This is not to say that other places that offer frozen cod and a beautiful batter are not amazing as well, because there are a lot of incredible fish and chips restaurants along this island. In our column however, we are looking to focus on the places that use locally sourced ingredients as the mainstay of why we want to interview them and share their stories with all of you.
Their secondary menu consists of whatever the fresh catch of the day right out of our sea at St. Pauls Bay may be. This part of the menu changes daily. The day we came to visit, we not only got to eat my favourite perch and chips, but we also got to sample the most incredible, fresh, perfectly grilled-to-order swordfish that had just come in less than an hour before.
Here is where Fins and Gills gets lucky: across the street is the fresh fish shop, Connies. Not only do they fish every morning bright and early to put the freshest caught fish available out for its customers, but Connie also happens to be Davids mother! Talk about a win win combination right there.
Not only did we get to eat the most delectably fresh and delicious swordfish, but while we were there they brought in a brand-new large piece of fresh tuna!
When you visit Fins and Gills, be ready to get any one of the five regular menu items, or ask about the fish of the day on their secondary menu.